386 – Will the real Philo please stand up?

I performed a public service yesterday . I told two relatively new teen-age gamers The Eric & the Gazebo story.

Now, for those of you who have never heard this particular story, it is an anecdotal story that has been bopping around the gaming world since about the mid-1980s, courtesy of game designer Richard Aronson. Here is the story in its entirety, or as near as anyone can manage on the Internet:

Let us cast our minds back to the early days of Fantasy Role Playing, back when ye Dread Gygax was loose upon the land. Funny how humor and horror can start out so alike. Let us go still earlier (yes, it is permitted to breathe sighs of relief) to the days before Gygax (and the courts) thought that he owned FRP. In the early seventies, Ed Whitchurch ran ďhis game,Ē and one of the participants was Eric Sorenson, a veritable giant of a man. This story is essentially true: I know both Ed and Eric, and neither denies it (although Eric, for reasons that will become apparent, never repeats it either). If my telling of it does not match the actual events precisely, it is because Iíve heard it many different ways depending on how much of what type of intoxicants Ed had taken recently.

The gist of it is that Eric, well, you need a bit more about Eric, or else I wonít fill quota. Eric comes quite close to being a computer. When he games, he methodically considers each possibility before choosing his preferred option. If given time, he will invariably pick the optimum solution. It has been known to take weeks. He is otherwise in all respects a superior gamer, and Iíve spent many happy hours competing with and against him, as long as he is given enough time.

So, Eric was playing a Neutral Paladin (why should only Lawful Good religions get to have holy warriors was the thinking) in Edís game. He even had a holy sword, which fought well, and did all those things holy swords are supposed to do, including detect good (random die roll; it could have detected evil). He was on some lordís lands when the following exchange occurred:

ED: You see a well groomed garden. In the middle, on a small hill, you see a gazebo.
ERIC: A gazebo? What color is it?
ED: (Pause) Itís white, Eric.
ERIC: How far away is it?
ED: About fifty yards.
ERIC: How big is it?
ED: (Pause) Itís about thirty feet across, fifteen feet high, with a pointed top.
ERIC: I use my sword to detect good on it.
ED: Itís not good, Eric. Itís a gazebo!
ERIC: (Pause) I call out to it.
ED: It wonít answer. Itís a gazebo!
ERIC: (Pause) I sheathe my sword and draw my bow and arrows. Does it respond in any way?
ED: No, Eric, itís a gazebo!
ERIC: I shoot it with my bow (roll to hit). What happened?
ED: There is now a gazebo with an arrow sticking out of it.
ERIC: (Pause) Wasnít it wounded?
ED: Of course not, Eric! Itís a gazebo!
ERIC: (Whimper) But that was a plus three arrow!
ED: Itís a gazebo, Eric, a gazebo! If you really want to try to destroy it, you could try to chop it with an axe, I suppose, or you could try to burn it, but I donít know why anybody would even try. Itís a *)@#! gazebo!
ERIC: (Long pause. He has no axe or fire spells.) I run away.
ED: (Thoroughly frustrated) Itís too late. Youíve woken up the gazebo, and it catches you and eats you.
ERIC: (Reaching for his dice) Maybe Iíll roll up a fire-using mage so I can avenge my Paladin.

At this point, the increasingly amused fellow party members restored a modicum of order by explaining what a gazebo is. It is solely an afterthought, of course, but Eric is doubly lucky that the gazebo was not situated on a grassy gnoll.

Unfortunately, my rendition of it was nowhere near as complete as this one was, for which I humbly apologize to Sam and Cody, the recipients of this nugget of D&D history.

If you’d like to learn more about it, please visit Corey and Lori’s Quest Log, which goes into even more detail regarding the history of…. The Gazebo!

Take care,


%d bloggers like this: